Peanut butter is eaten in over 90% of American households. Every year, we consume about 700 million pounds of it. If most of us were forced to choose just three food items that we would never let our pantry or kitchen cupboards be without, one of those foods would likely be peanut butter. But which of the dozens of types of peanut butters out there is best for our PB&J sandwiches, peanut butter cookies, shakes, smoothies, or just spooning straight from the jar for a quick snack to quell our cravings? Read on to find out, as we take you through our selection of the top 5 peanut butters on the market in 2020.
We reviewed dozens of peanut butters to identify the best of the best. We examined a range of factors, including taste, ingredients, tub size, healthiness, cost, and average customer reviews. All of these top-rated peanut butters can be purchased online at Amazon.com.
Having considered a large number of peanut butters, we chose the JIF Peanut Butter Spread as our top pick. A nationawide favorite for more than sixty years, this peanut butter scores high on taste and value for money and is also low sodium, is non-GMO, and has a smooth, velvety texture that’s ideal for spreading on sandwiches and toast or adding to baking mixtures for peanut butter bread, pancakes, waffles, and more.
The 5 Top-Rated Peanut Butters
| Editor's Picks | Brand | Rating |
|---|---|---|
| Best Peanut Butter Overall | JIF Peanut Butter Spread | 4.7 |
| Best Crunchy Peanut Butter | Crazy Richard's All Natural Crunchy Peanut Butter | 4.4 |
| Best Budget Peanut Butter | Skippy Creamy Peanut Butter | 4.5 |
| Best Natural Peanut Butter | Teddie All Natural Peanut Butter | 4.5 |
| Best Powdered Peanut Butter | PBfit All-Natural Organic Peanut Butter Powder | 4.8 |
*Ratings are from Amazon at the time of publication and can change
Best Peanut Butter Overall: JIF Peanut Butter Spread
Tried, tested, trusted, and almost universally adored, it’s very hard to go wrong with JIF Peanut Butter Spread.
This peanut butter has been a regualr feature in households all over North America for decades and, despite many pretenders to its throne, has withstood the test of time by remaining the most popular peanut butter brand out there by some margin.
Made with simple ingredients, this peanut butter has that delicious, fresh-roasted peanut taste that all of us know and love. Its smooth texture is also easy to spread and ideal for sandwiches, toast, eating straight from the spoon or baking peanut butter cookies and breads.
In addition to packing simply oodles of flavor into every spoonful, JIF’s Smooth Peanut Butter Spread is also a relatively healthy option, boasting 7 grams of protein per serving, using no preservatives, and having a lower sodium content than many competitor brands. And at just over $2 per tub, the value-for-money box is well and truly ticked…!
JIF Peanut Butter Spread Key Features:
- 16-ounce tub
- Smooth
- 7 grams of protein per serving
- Fresh-roasted peanut taste
- Low sodium
- Non-GMO
Best Crunchy Peanut Butter: Crazy Richard’s All Natural Crunchy Peanut Butter
Crazy Richard’s All Natural Crunchy Peanut Butter is the ideal choice for buyers who priotize texture as much as they do taste.
Made with 100% peanuts, this all-natural peanut butter is in a league of its own when it comes to crunch levels and boasts a rich, clean flavor profile sure delight the taste buds of anyone with a more discerning palate that can detect traces of additives in the peanut butters made by other brands.
What we love most about this peanut butter is that it delivers impressively on the taste and texture fronts without compromising on healthiness—not only is the Crazy Richard’s All Natural Crunchy Peanut Butter non-GMO, gluten-free, and certified kosher, it also uses no palm oil, no added sugar, and no added salt.
While a little harder to stir and spread than some of the smooth varities of peanut butter in our review, this minor inconvenience is a small price to pay for Crazy Richard’s crazily good taste, use of only the healthiest ingredients, and perfect chunk-to-butter ratio.
Crazy Richard’s All Natural Crunchy Peanut Butter Key Features:
- 3 x 16-ounce jars
- 100% peanuts
- Non-GMO, cerified kosher, and gluten free
- No palm oil, added sugar, or added salt
- Crazy Richard’s donates 10% of resources to the Healthy Kids Happy Future Project
Best Budget Peanut Butter: Skippy Creamy Peanut Butter
This eight pack of Skippy Creamy Peanut Butter is the ideal choice for those keen to get as much bang for their buck as possible when stocking their panty with tasty, longlife edibles. At only $2.25 per 16.3-ounce jar, it doesn’t get much better than this interms of value for money…
The no-stir texture and consistency make this sweet, creamy peanut butter spread ideally suited to sandwiches and toast, but its slightly more subtle flavor profile also makes it a good option for cookies, frostings, smoothies, and even savory dishes. Unlike many other cheaper peanut butters out there, this one also requires no stirring to keep the oil and butter together, is easy to spread, and is also gluten free, uses no added preservatives, certified kosher, and contains no artificial flavors or colors.
Skippy Creamy Peanut Butter Key Features:
- Pack contains eight 16.3-ounce jars
- 7 grams of protein per serving
- Smooth texture
- Easy to spread
- Gluten free
- Certified kosher
- Contains no artificial flavors or colors.
Best Natural Peanut Butter: Teddie All Natural Peanut Butter
Teddie All Natural Peanut Butter is is the number 1 bestselling natural peanut butter in the northeastern US and a great choice for buyers who a peanut butter that’s full of fresh, wholesome flavors and free of any unhealthy additives or artificial colors or flavorings.
More than any other peanut butter we know of, Teddie All Natural Peanut Butter is one that lets the peanuts do the talking—there are no oils, sweeteners, or any other additives to hide the natural goodness of the peanut butter, just 100% fresh-roasted and ground, USA-grown peanuts and a pinch of salt, all of which make it, if you like, a 24-karat version of the 12 to 18-karat peanut butters lower down the price scale (!). While the oil in Teddie’s tends to separate from the butter, this is a natural occurrence and can be easily remedied by simply storing the jar in the fridge between uses.
All in all, one of the healthiest options out there and ideal for sandwiches, smoothies, or straight-from-the-spoon eating alike!
Teddie All Natural Peanut Butter Key Features:
- Pack contains 3 x 26-ounce jars
- 100% natural ingredients
- 8 grams of protein per serving
- Made with USA-grown peanuts
- No artificial colors or flavorings
- Lightly salted
Best Powdered Peanut Butter: PBfit All-Natural Organic Peanut Butter Powder
The PBfit All-Natural Organic Peanut Butter Powder is, in essence, peanut butter 2.0, taking everything we’ve always loved about peanut butter and making it even better.
Made with whole-roasted organic peanuts, PBfit contains all the taste of traditional peanut butter spreads but also 87% less fat and only about a third of the calories. But what we love most about the PBfot power is its versatility. While ideally suited for adding to shakes and smoothies, this powder is also perfect for making peanut butter cookies or oatmeal and can also be used as a taste and protein-booster when sprinkled over your panckakes or waffles or added to your homemade bread mix. And if you just want to spread it on a sandwich or lick it from the spoon, that’s easily done, too—all you have to do is add a few spoonfuls of water, give it a stir, and within seconds you’ll have a rich, smooth, guilt-free snack that looks and tastes just like regular peanut butter (but, in our opinion, just a little bit better!).
PBfit All-Natural Organic Peanut Butter Powder Key Features:
- 30-ounce jar
- 87% less fat than other peanut butter
- 33% less calories than tradition peanut butter
- 8 grams of protein
- Ideal for shakes, smoothies, and baking
- Gluten free
If you’re one of the millions of Americans for whom peanut butter is a non-negotiable feature on the shelves of the pantry, these top-rated peanut butters are a great choice. For more kitchen products that can help you cook and prepare whatever else you choose to stock those shelves with, check out our reviews of the Best Electric Can Openers and the Best Pour Over Coffee Makers.
