Creating a homemade pasta sauce from scratch is great and all, but who has the time? Lucky for us there are a number of delicious and nutritious pre-made pasta sauces out there that taste as good as mom’s family recipe. Convenience is king, but flavor matters too. We found several pasta sauces from family-owned companies that are made with love, just like mom’s pasta sauce, and now we’re going to share them with you.
After looking at dozens of different pasta sauces we have identified the best available online. While researching the sauces we considered factors such as ingredient selection, ingredient quality, and overall flavor to choose our top picks. Below we have listed the best pasta sauces you can buy online at Amazon, and we think they’re good enough that you’ll want to impress your friends by passing them off as your own homemade creation.
We painstakingly deliberated the deliciousness of each sauce we reviewed and ultimately chose Papa Vince Tomato Sauce as our overall top pick. It’s a simple four-ingredient sauce made from the best ingredients possible, and it is utterly delightful to eat with any type of pasta.
In This Article
The 5 Top-Rated Pasta Sauces
|Best Pasta Sauce Overall||Papa Vince Tomato Sauce||4.6|
|Best Vodka Pasta Sauce||Hoboken Farms Vodka Sauce||4.7|
|Best Budget Pasta Sauce||Hunt's Pasta Sauce||3.8|
|Best Bolognese Pasta Sauce||Hudson Green Bolognese Pasta Sauce||4.6|
|Best Marinara Sauce||Hoboken Farms Gourmet Marinara Pasta Sauce||4.5|
*Ratings are from Amazon at the time of publication and can change
Best Pasta Sauce Overall: Papa Vince Tomato Sauce
When simplicity is done right, it can lead to perfection. Papa Vince Tomato Sauce is a simple four-ingredient pasta sauce with a wonderful flavor that sings of Sicilian heritage and brings you into Papa Vince’s grandmother’s kitchen of yore. Vine-ripened red cherry tomatoes, extra virgin olive oil, Italian basil, and sea salt are the only ingredients in this delicious pasta sauce. It’s like you’ve got your own seat at the family table.
Picked at the peak of freshness in the farmlands of Ragusa, Italy by friends of the Papa Vince family, the tomatoes impart a beautifully vibrant flavor into the sauce that is complemented by the subtle fragrance and taste of Italian basil. Those tomatoes were harvested at the height of summer to ensure maximum sweetness and the lowest possible acidity. The low acid of this pasta sauce makes it an excellent option for those who suffer from frequent heartburn or acid reflux disease. Customers who suffer from IBS have found this to be a safe sauce to consume as well.
This pasta sauce is as simple as it gets, yet the quality of its ingredients is second to none. Made in Italy from ingredients grown in Italy, this is a truly authentic pasta sauce that started out as Papa Vince’s grandmother’s own recipe and has not changed as it passed through several generations of the family. Papa Vince states that each batch has been made from a separate tomato harvest, and so each time you open a new bottle it may have a slightly different taste than the last. That’s how you know this pasta sauce is real, fresh, and natural.
Papa Vince Tomato Sauce Key Features:
- Four ingredient blend
- Uses vine-ripened cherry tomatoes
- No preservatives
- Made in Italy
Best Vodka Pasta Sauce: Hoboken Farms Vodka Sauce
It might seem a bit overzealous to say that Hoboken Farms Vodka Sauce is heaven in a bottle, but with farm-fresh plum tomatoes, rich heavy cream, mouth-watering Italian cheeses, and a dash of vodka mixed into this decadent pasta sauce, we think the description is apt, and past customers agree. Those core ingredients are further combined with freshly-picked basil, garlic, onions, butter, and more to complete this luxurious vodka sauce.
While deliciousness may be the key driver behind the creation of Hoboken Farms Vodka Sauce, it’s also been wisely crafted to work with a number of dietary restrictions. This vodka sauce is gluten-free, Keto certified, uses kosher dairy, and contains no added sugar. The company’s slogan rings true here, stating, “We are not just a better sauce, we are a better sauce for you.”
Hoboken Farms is a family-owned American company that started out by selling their products at a local farmer market. They still sell at over 30 farmer markets to this day and are now emerging as a national brand thanks to their stellar sauces and customer word of mouth. Hoboken Farms was awarded Best Sauce in the Country by the Wall Street Journal in a blind taste test, and the brand has won an ADDY award. This is the best vodka sauce on the market, and soon the world will know its name. As it stands now, you’ve being told of this amazing sauce before most everyone else has heard of it. Better grab a jar before your neighbors find out!
Hoboken Farms Vodka Sauce Key Features:
- Made with all-natural plum tomatoes and heavy cream
- Kosher dairy
- Parmesan and Romano cheeses
- Keto certified
Best Budget Pasta Sauce: Hunt’s Pasta Sauce
Hunt’s Pasta Sauce is a well-balanced pasta sauce that can be heated and served as is or it can be used as a base to create your own unique flavor profile. The sauce is made from California vine-ripened tomatoes that have been slow-cooked to bring out their natural flavor. There are several different flavors of Hunt’s Pasta Sauce to choose from including traditional tomato sauce, zesty and spicy sauce, mushroom sauce, Italian sausage sauce, and more.
No matter which tasty flavor your choose, you’re going to get the sauce at a great value. Each listing is for 12 cans that hold 24 ounces of pasta sauce in each. At this price, that much sauce is certainly a bargain, and you’ll have plenty of it to add to many dishes to come. Not only does Hunt’s Pasta Sauce work wonderfully for many different types of pasta, but it can also be used as a pizza sauce or marinara dipping sauce as well.
This is a fantastic sauce made from fine ingredients that is a convenient option for times when crafting your own homemade sauce would be too time-consuming. Hunt’s Pasta Sauce is a family favorite because it is easy to prepare and provides a balanced flavor profile that everyone can enjoy. You can always spice up the sauce with a few dashes of herbs from your spice rack. All of the ingredients in this pasta sauce are non-GMO certified.
Hunt’s Pasta Sauce Key Features:
- 12 cans holding 24 ounces each
- Several flavors to choose from
- Made from California vine-ripened tomatoes
- Non-GMO verified ingredients
Best Bolognese Pasta Sauce: Hudson Green Bolognese Pasta Sauce
Traditions were made to be broken. There are plenty of meaty, creamy, and oil-laden bolognese sauces out there to choose from, but this Hudson Green Bolognese Pasta Sauce breaks the mold by creating its hearty recipe purely from vegetables and walnuts. The result is a silky smooth sauce with large vegetable chunks that mirrors the appearance and flavor of traditional bolognese sauce without the overabundance of fat and meat that usually goes along with it.
This nutrient-rich sauce is made from an organic blend of sun-dried tomatoes, cauliflower, onions, carrots, walnuts, mushrooms, olive oil, garlic, salt, and spices. It’s gluten-free and vegan. There’s no added sugar because none is needed when the ripened tomatoes are naturally sweetened and picked at the peak of flavor. You can always add your own meat and cream to this delectable sauce if you want to beef it up, but it certainly stands well on its own as a sumptuous pasta sauce.
Customers say that this vegan pasta sauce truly tastes like a traditional bolognese. Hudson Green was formed by a mother and son team who are on a mission to create the most delicious plant-based sauces on the market, and they’ve definitely succeeded with this Bolognese Pasta Sauce. If you haven’t tried a meatless bolognese sauce, now is the time. As we said, you can always add your own meat if you so desire!
Hudson Green Bolognese Pasta Sauce Key Features:
- Vegan meatless bolognese sauce
- USDA Organic
- No added sugar
Best Marinara Pasta Sauce: Hoboken Farms Gourmet Marinara Pasta Sauce
A staple of the finest artisanal Italian cuisine, and reliable standby in just about every home kitchen, marinara sauce is the preferred pasta sauce of many people around the world. Hoboken Farms Gourmet Marinara Pasta Sauce is a great example of what any marinara sauce should aspire to be— a basic tomato sauce made from simple, high-quality ingredients that are packed with natural flavor. It’s a tried-and-true recipe for success.
Featured on our list for a second time, Hoboken Farms has made another best-in-class sauce using the best ingredients to create a delicious sauce that is also accommodating of common dietary restrictions. The all-natural ingredients in this pasta sauce are non-GMO verified, Keto certified, paleo-friendly, vegan, gluten-free, and cholesterol-free. This marinara sauce is comprised purely of whole tomatoes, golden olive oil, fresh onion, garlic, basil, sea salt, and a few secret spices.
But, above all else, this is simply an outstanding, delicious marinara sauce. It is versatile in that it can be used as a pasta sauce for any type of pasta, a pizza sauce, a dipping sauce, or in any number of tasty ways. The sauce has been well-blended for a smooth consistency, but it hasn’t been overly processed so far as to remove the pleasing texture of the small bits of tomato you will find in every bite.
Hoboken Farms Gourmet Marinara Pasta Sauce Key Features:
- All-natural ingredients
- Keto certified
- Gluten and cholesterol-free
- Non-GMO verified
A great pasta sauce can turn a simple dinner into a memorable meal. We hope that by reading this article you’ve found the perfect pasta sauce for your next pasta dinner. If you need a tool to open all of the Hunt’s Pasta Sauce cans you have just purchased, we’ve put together a rundown of the Best Electric Can Openers on the market that’ll get the job done fast and easy.